Shareholder Protection in Saudi Companies Law: Assessing Merger and Acquisition Efficacy for Unlisted Joint Stock Companies
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.59992/IJSR.2024.v3n4p16الكلمات المفتاحية:
Merger، Acquisition، Unlisted Joint Stock Company، Companies Law، Legal Protection، Shareholdersالملخص
This paper explores the legal protections afforded to shareholders of unlisted joint stock companies in Saudi Arabia during merger and acquisition activities. There are significant risks associated with using tools like mergers and acquisitions, including market share loss and decreased profitability for shareholders. Thus, this study aims to analyse the Saudi Companies Law for potential gaps that may affect shareholder legal protections. The researchers primarily use a doctrinal legal methodology to assess the legal framework. This approach provides that the study is based on an examination of the legal framework of Saudi Arabia such as statutes, rules, principles, and cases[1]. It will also apply the analytical approach to evaluate the legal framework's fundamentals, conceptual problems, and practical effects, to make sure that the study finds opportunities for improvement. The Article identifies the differences between unlisted and listed companies concerning document disclosure requirements, lack of the method used for asset valuation, lack of forward-looking information disclosure, the absence of obligatory independent financial reports and unclear definitions of shareholder rights to oppose or exit mergers and acquisitions at fair value. The study found that these areas represent potential gaps that could undermine shareholders of unlisted joint stock, improvements to the law, such as the adoption of independent valuation standards, mandatory financial disclosures, and clearer expression of shareholder rights.
[1] Hurchinson, T & Duncan, N (2012), Defining and Describing What We Do: Doctrinal Legal Research by ResearchGate, P.85.
المراجع
1. The Companies Law 2022. Available at: https://mc.gov.sa/ar/Documents/SEN.pdf
2. Implementing Regulation of The Companies Law 2023. Available at: chrome-extension://efaidnbmnnnibpcajpcglclefindmkaj/https://mc.gov.sa/ar/Documents/R.pdf
3. The Merger and Acquisition Regulation 2023, Available at: https://cma.org.sa/en/RulesRegulations/Regulations/Documents/Merger%20and%20Acquisition%20Regulations.pdf.
4. The Corporate Governance Regulations for unlisted joint stock companies,2018. Available at: https://ncar.gov.sa/documentdetails/eyJpdiI6Im11Qi9hZWg2RlkySEFKajQrRVYxV1E9PSIsInZhbHVlIjoiZkZWWXBsKzZDdnJIRTRRK05SUC9wdz09IiwibWFjIjoiMWIyZmE5NmNjMDdkNTFhZTBlOTNmYTMxYjFjMWUyODE2OTA0MWFlYTM5OThkMWE0NDkzNTFkNDkwOTVmOTM5YyIsInRhZyI6IiJ9
5. The Companies Act 71,2008. Available at: https://www.gov.za/documents/companies-act
6. The New Zealand Companies Act, 1993. Available at: https://www.legislation.govt.nz/act/public/1993/0105/latest/DLM319570.html
7. Saxena, S. (2012) Mergers and Acquisitions As A Strategic Tool To Gain Competitive Advantage By Exploiting Synergies: A Study Of Merging & Non Merging Firms In Indian Aluminium Industry, SSRN Electronic Journal.
8. Directorate For Financial And Enterprise Affairs, Investment Division, Oecd. (2004) Paper #4 Mergers And Acqisitions (M&As).
9. Dilshad, M (2013) Profitability Analysis of Mergers and Acquisitions: An Event Study Approach, Business and Economic Research, V.3.
10. Nurcahyo, N. Taruno, Y (2018). Analysis of Validity Decisions General Meeting of Shareholders Limited Liability Company in Circulation, International Journal of Multicultural and Multireligious Understanding, V.5.
11. Qimatshoeva, Q (2020) Private Equity and Investors Exit Rights: an Analysis of “Tag Along” and “Drag Along” clauses,central European University.
12. Justisiana, R. Pangaribuan, T (2022). Drag-Along and Tag-Along Rights in the Perspective of Indonesian Company Law, Sociological Jurisprudence Journal, V.5.
13. Marsden, M. Zick, C.D. Mayer, R.N (2011). The Value of Seeking Financial Advice.
14. Nilsson, H (2003) Essays on the value relevance of financial statement information.
15. Burkart, M. Panunzi, F (2003) Mandatory Bids, Squeeze-out, Sell-out and the Dynamics of the Tender Offer Process, European Corporate Governance Institute (ECGI) - Law Research Paper Series.
16. Carvalho, M (2019) Mergers and Acquisitions of Private versus Public firms: The European Case.
17. Do, T. Osma, B. Simats, A. Zhu, F (2023) Shareholder Voting and Disclosure in M&As, European Corporate Governance Institute – Finance, Paper No. 879/2023.
18. Al-Hemyari, A (2012) Merger and Acquisition Laws in UK,UAE and Qatar: Transferring Rights and Obligation, Brunel University London.
19. Papadopoulos T (2021) Protiction of Shareholders in cross-border merger: the new harmonized rules, European Company and Financial Law Review-ECFR (De Gruyter), V.18.
20. Matthews, G. (2020) The “market exception” in appraisal statutes, Harvad Law School Forum on Corporate Governance.
21. Almulhim, M (2016) A Critique of Saudi M&A Laws, SJD.
22. Masondo, P (2018) The protection of shareholders and creditors in the context of takeovers and reorganizations under the Companies Act 71 of 2008, University of Pretoria.
23. Holderness, C. Sheehan, D (2000) Constraints on Large-Block Shareholders, https://www.nber.org/books-and-chapters/concentrated-corporate-ownership/constraints-large-block-shareholders.
24. Hurchinson, T & Duncan, N (2012) Defining and Describing What We Do: Doctrinal Legal Research by ResearchGate.
